Repository logo
 

Garnet and spinel oxybarometers: New internally consistent multi-equilibria models with applications to the oxidation state of the lithospheric mantle

Accepted version
Peer-reviewed

Change log

Authors

Miller, WGR 
Holland, TJB 
Gibson, SA 

Abstract

New thermodynamic data for skiagite garnet (Fe 3 Fe 2 3+ Si 3 O 12 ) are derived from experimental phase-equilibrium data that extend to 10 GPa and are applied to oxybarometry of mantle peridotites using a revised six-component garnet mixing model. Skiagite is more stable by 12 kJ mol -1 than in a previous calibration of the equilibrium 2 skiagite = 4 fayalite + ferrosilite + O 2 , and this leads to calculated oxygen fugacities that are higher (more oxidized) by around 1-1.5 log fO 2 units. A new calculation method and computer program incorporates four independent oxybarometers (including 2 pyrope + 2 andradite + 2 ferrosilite = 2 grossular + 4 fayalite + 3 enstatite + O 2 ) for use on natural peridotite samples to yield optimum log fO 2 estimates by the method of least squares. These estimates should be more robust than those based on any single barometer and allow assessment of possible disequilibrium in assemblages. A new set of independent oxybarometers for spinel-bearing peridotites is also presented here, including a new reaction 2 magnetite + 3 enstatite = 3 fayalite + 3 forsterite + O 2 . These recalibrations combined with internally consistent PT determinations for published analyses of mantle peridotites with analysed Fe 2 O 3 data for garnets, from both cratonic (Kaapvaal, Siberia and Slave) and circumcratonic (Baikal Rift) regions, provide revised estimates of oxidation state in the lithospheric mantle. Estimates of log fO 2 for spinel assemblages are more reduced than those based on earlier calibrations, whereas garnet-bearing assemblages are more oxidized. Importantly, this lessens considerably the difference between garnet and spinel oxybarometry that was observed with previous published calibrations.

Description

Keywords

peridotite, oxybarometry, igneous petrology, mantle

Journal Title

Journal of Petrology

Conference Name

Journal ISSN

1460-2415
1460-2415

Volume Title

57

Publisher

OUP
Sponsorship
This work was supported by a Natural Environment Research Council studentship [NE/L501578/1] to W. Miller.