jats:pFreshwater ecosystems provide essential resources and vital ecosystem services. These ecosystems exist in a delicate state of balance and are under increasing anthropogenic and climatic pressures. One of the major anthropogenic threats to freshwater ecosystems is eutrophication that often leads to algal blooms, some of which may be extremely harmful. Current chemical and physical interventions to prevent algal blooms can be expensive, ephemeral and disruptive to other aspects of the ecosystem. Therefore, there is interest in utilising biological methods of control. This study aimed to assess the viability of allelopathic repression of nuisance algae species by invasive aquatic plants. The allelopathic effect of jats:italicHydrocotyle ranunculoides</jats:italic> (Floating Pennywort) and jats:italicCrassula helmsii</jats:italic> (Swamp Stonecrop) were tested in both whole plant and crushed plant states for their ability to affect the average population growth of monocultures and co-cultures of the green algae jats:italicChlorella vulgaris</jats:italic> and the cyanobacterium jats:italicSynechocystis</jats:italic> sp. PCC6803. Methanol extracts from these species have been identified in the literature to have high allelopathic potential. The key findings of this study are that, for jats:italicChlorella</jats:italic>: whole jats:italicH. ranunculoides</jats:italic> and crushed jats:italicC. helmsii</jats:italic> had a negative effect on the average population growth; whole jats:italicH. ranunculoides</jats:italic> had a greater negative effect than crushed jats:italicH. ranunculoides</jats:italic>; and crushed jats:italicC. helmsii</jats:italic> had a more negative effect than crushed jats:italicH. ranunculoides</jats:italic>. For jats:italicSynechocystis</jats:italic>: crushed jats:italicC. helmsii</jats:italic> had a greater negative effect on the average population growth than crushed jats:italicH. ranunculoides</jats:italic>; and the presence of jats:italicChlorella</jats:italic> in co-culture experiments had a universally positive effect on its average population growth. The species-specific nature of these allelopathic interactions suggests that the use of allelopathy for algal bloom control may have to be assessed on a case-by-case basis and the use of combination treatments should be assessed. Moreover, the effects exerted by allelochemicals in open water systems is likely to be direct, indirect and context specific. Although this study explores the possibility of embracing the allelopathic potential of invasive aquatic plants, we do not encourage novel introductions of invasive species into open freshwater systems. However, potential allelopathic effects could be leveraged in already invaded systems, or in closed systems within an invaded range.</jats:p>