Truth as Conformation in Herbert of Cherbury
New Blackfriars: a review, edited by the Dominicans of the English Province
MetadataShow full item record
Pickstock, C. (2021). Truth as Conformation in Herbert of Cherbury. New Blackfriars: a review, edited by the Dominicans of the English Province, 102 (1102), 857-872. https://doi.org/10.1111/nbfr.12602
The theory of truth as 'conformation' in the writings of Edward Herbert is not put forward as an epistemological theory, nor as a theory of representation. Indeed, one could hazard that it possesses features which anticipate postmodern critique, though it is necessarily rooted in a pre-modern and Renaissance sensibility. This essay explores the way in which, in De Veritate, Herbert is not arguing that the mind must ‘conform’ to things in their given evidence, and be constrained by this. Nor is he saying that the evidence which one receives through one’s senses must be ‘conformed’ to the way in which one’s mind works, or to its a priori categories of understanding. Rather, by conformation he is referring to a phenomenon of the Platonic metaxu, or of what William Desmond calls ‘the between’. Truthful understanding is possible because there is a natural relation, analogy or harmony between things and mind, a kind of occult or sympathetic echo or affinity. One’s understanding is an instance of the general analogy which pertains between one thing and another, of their inherent connectedness which cannot be understood in terms of mechanism, but rather of secret ‘affinities’, ‘emanations’, foreshadowings, and the construals of the ‘signature’ of one thing by another.
Original Article, Original Articles, Truth, Aquinas, Herbert McCabe OP, Hubert Dreyfus, Locke
External DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/nbfr.12602
This record's URL: https://www.repository.cam.ac.uk/handle/1810/331445