Confession and intimacy in England, 1851-1913
Repository URI
Repository DOI
Change log
Authors
Abstract
This thesis examines the history of confession as an intimate practice in England through four microhistorical case studies. In the introduction, I briefly outline a broad history of confession and trace the outline of what I argue already forms the history of intimacy. I propose that a promising way to deepen the study of the history of intimacy is to study intimate practices. I further suggest that the history of nineteenth-century confession—in both the Roman Catholic Church and the Church of England—offers fruitful material with which to do this. The first chapter looks at the 1852 ‘Achilli Trial’, in which a convert ex-priest sued John Henry Newman for libel. The second chapter follows the development of confession in the Church of England through a controversial book written for priests wishing to hear confessions, which became the subject of a major scandal in 1877. The third chapter deals with a confessional scandal in Kensington, culminating in allegations of the breaching of the seal of the confessional in 1882. Throughout, I seek to use confession to illustrate broader themes, drawing on cases relating to medical surgery, divorce law, detective work, legal practice, obscenity legislation and, finally, trance mediumship; the final chapter turns to the Society for Psychical Research, and examines the way secrets took on evidentiary value in what I argue was an intimate science. Overall, this thesis argues that confession was not only the site of broader cultural anxieties about gender and sexuality, but that it was a practice which united proponents and opponents in awareness of its radical, and potentially threatening, intimacy. It thus allows us to construct a history of intimacy in modern Britain with broader implications. This thesis contains discussion of sexual violence, suicide, abortion, drug use, and female genital mutilation.
Description
Date
Advisors
Keywords
Qualification
Awarding Institution
Rights
Sponsorship
AHRC (1964217)
Arts and Humanities Research Council (1964217)