Repository logo
 

From social choice to inequality-decomposition: in the spirit of Arrow and Atkinson by way of Sen and Shorrocks

Accepted version
Peer-reviewed

Type

Article

Change log

Abstract

This article forges connections between social choice theory and inequality-measurement to deliver a series of advances to the latter. It discusses the ethical and formal aspects connecting the fields, linking the roles played by the intensity of preferences and interpersonal comparability (in social choice) and, respectively, inequality-aversion and interpersonal comparability (in inequality-measurement). This extends naturally to relaxing the assumption of symmetry in group-wise inequality-decompositions, allowing a measure capable of unambiguous decomposition that, overcoming well-known limitations of existing measures, still incorporates different degrees of inequality-aversion through use of its demonstrated duality with inter-group comparability. The framework is then applied to inequality in Brazil and the changes it underwent between 2003 and 2015, focusing on labour-market incomes of white men and non-white women. We show how sensitive are measures of (changes in) inequality to assumptions regarding the interpersonal comparability of the groups' income and inequality-aversion, pinpointing the precise trade-offs between the two. The results indicate that, for a reasonable range of parameters, overall inequality changed by between -28.6% and -12.2% over the period. This highlights the analysis of the trade-off between interpersonal comparability and inequality-aversion warrants being addressed explicitly in empirical measurements of, or judgements over, levels and variations of inequality.

Description

Keywords

Inequality measurement, social choice, inequality decomposition, Brazil, ethnoracial inequality, gender inequality

Journal Title

International Review of Applied Economics

Conference Name

Journal ISSN

0269-2171
1465-3486

Volume Title

35

Publisher

Informa UK Limited

Rights

All rights reserved