Repository logo

Target revaluation after failed takeover attempts - cash versus stock

Change log


Malmendier, U 
Opp, MM 
Saidi-Varnosafaderani, F 


Cash- and stock-financed takeover bids induce strikingly different target revaluations. We exploit detailed data on unsuccessful takeover bids between 1980 and 2008, and we show that targets of cash offers are revalued on average by +15% after deal failure, whereas stock targets return to their pre-announcement levels. The differences in revaluation do not revert over longer horizons. We find no evidence that future takeover activities or operational changes explain these differences. While the targets of failed cash and stock offers are both more likely to be acquired over the following eight years than matched control firms, no differences exist between cash and stock targets, neither in the timing nor in the value of future offers. Similarly, we cannot detect differential operational policies following the failed bid. Our results are most consistent with cash bids revealing prior undervaluation of the target. We reconcile our findings with the opposite conclusion in earlier literature (Bradley, Desai, and Kim, 1983) by identifying a look-ahead bias built into their sample construction.



Mergers and acquisitions, Synergies, Revaluation, Medium of exchange

Journal Title

Journal of Financial Economics

Conference Name

Journal ISSN


Volume Title



Elsevier BV