Repository logo
 

Uncertainty quantification for data-driven turbulence modelling with Mondrian forests

Accepted version
Peer-reviewed

Type

Article

Change log

Authors

Scillitoe, A 
Seshadri, P 

Abstract

Data-driven turbulence modelling approaches are gaining increasing interest from the CFD community. However, the introduction of a machine learning (ML) model introduces a new source of uncertainty, the ML model itself. Quantification of this uncertainty is essential since the predictive capability of a data-driven model diminishes when predicting physics not seen during training. In this work, we explore the suitability of Mondrian forests (MF's) for data-driven turbulence modelling. MF's are claimed to possess many of the advantages of the commonly used random forest (RF) machine learning algorithm, whilst offering principled uncertainty estimates. An example test case is constructed, with a turbulence anisotropy constant derived from high fidelity turbulence resolving simulations. Shapley values, borrowed from game theory, are used to interpret the MF predictions. Predictive uncertainty is found to be large in regions where the training data is not representative. Additionally, the MF predictive uncertainty is found to exhibit stronger correlation with predictive errors compared to an a priori statistical distance measure, which indicates it is a better measure of prediction confidence. The MF predictive uncertainty is also found to be better calibrated and less computationally costly than the uncertainty estimated from applying jackknifing to random forest predictions. Finally, Mondrian forests are used to predict the Reynolds discrepancies in a convergent-divergent channel, which are subsequently propagated through a modified CFD solver. The resulting flowfield predictions are in close agreement with the high fidelity data. A procedure for sampling the Mondrian forests' uncertainties is introduced. Propagating these samples enables quantification of the uncertainty in output quantities of interest.

Description

Keywords

Uncertainty quantification, Supervised machine learning, Turbulence modelling, Dataset shift, Mondrian forests, Machine learning interpretability

Journal Title

Journal of Computational Physics

Conference Name

Journal ISSN

0021-9991
1090-2716

Volume Title

430

Publisher

Elsevier BV
Sponsorship
EPSRC (via Alan Turing Institute) (EP/T001569/1)