How Collections End: Objects, Meaning and Loss in Laboratories and Museums

Change log
Kowal, Emma 
Bangham, Jenny 

Collections are made and maintained for pleasure, status, nation or empire building, cultural capital, as a substrate for knowledge production, and everything in between. In asking how collections end, we shift the focus from acquisition and growth to erosion, loss and decay, and expose the intellectual, material and curatorial labour required to maintain collections. In this introductory essay, we draw together insights from the history of science and from science and technology studies to investigate the dispersal, destruction, absorption, repurposing and repatriation of the diverse scientific collections discussed in the papers that make up this issue of BJHS Themes, and many other collections besides. We develop a distinction first suggested by the bibliographer John Willis Clark between ‘working’ collections of objects valued for the information they hold or produce, and ‘unique’ collections of objects valued for their historical singularity. We show that in many cases, the ‘end’ of an object or collection is merely a shift in the dominant account of its cultural value from ‘working’ to ‘unique’ or vice versa. Moving between the laboratory, the museum, and difficult-to-classify spaces in between, we argue that ‘ending’ is not anathema to ‘collecting’ but is always present as a threat, or as an everyday reality, or even as a necessary part of a collection’s continued existence. A focus on ending draws attention not only to the complex internal dynamics and social contexts of collections, but also to their roles in producing scientific knowledge.

43 History, Heritage and Archaeology, 4302 Heritage, Archive and Museum Studies, 4303 Historical Studies, 50 Philosophy and Religious Studies, 5002 History and Philosophy Of Specific Fields, Behavioral and Social Science, Basic Behavioral and Social Science
Journal Title
British Journal for the History of Science
Conference Name
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Cambridge University Press
Isaac Newton Trust (1508(j))
Leverhulme Trust (ECF-2015-047)