This paper introduces a method to produce high-quality transcrip- tions of speech data from only two crowd-sourced transcriptions. These transcriptions, produced cheaply by people on the Internet, for example through Amazon Mechanical Turk, are often of low qual- ity. Often, multiple crowd-sourced transcriptions are combined to form one transcription of higher quality. However, the state of the art is to use essentially a form of majority voting, which requires at least three transcriptions for each utterance. This paper shows how to refine this approach to work with only two transcriptions. It then introduces a method that uses a speech recogniser (bootstrapped on a simple combination scheme) to combine transcriptions. When only two crowd-sourced transcriptions are available, on a noisy data set this improves the word error rate to gold-standard transcriptions by 21 % relative.