In this paper, we revisit Radlow's highly original attempt at a double Wiener-Hopf solution to the canonical problem of wave diffraction by a quarter-plane. Using a constructive approach, we reduce the problem to two equations, one containing his somewhat controversial ansatz, and an additional compatibility equation. We then show that despite Radlow's ansatz being erroneous, it gives surprisingly accurate results in the far-field, particularly for the spherical diffraction coefficient. This unexpectedly good result is established by comparing it to results obtained by the recently established modified Smyshlyaev formulae.