Repository logo
 

Air pollution and anti-social behaviour: evidence from a randomized lab-in-the-field experiment

Published version
Peer-reviewed

Type

Article

Change log

Authors

Gsottbauer, Elisabeth 

Abstract

We conducted a pre-registered randomized lab-in-the-field online experiment in Beijing, China, to explore the relationship between acute air pollution and anti-social behaviour. Our novel experimental design exploits naturally occurring discontinuities in pollution episodes to mimic an experimental setting in which pollution exposure is exogenously manipulated, thus allowing us to identify a causal relationship. Participants were randomly assigned to be surveyed on either high pollution or low pollution days, thereby exogenously varying the degree of pollution exposure. In addition, a subset of individuals surveyed on the high-pollution days received an additional “pollution alert” to explore whether providing air pollution warnings influences (protective) behaviour. We used a set of well-established incentivised economic games to obtain clean measures of anti-social behaviour, as well as a range of secondary outcomes which may drive the proposed pollution-behaviour relationship. Our results indicate that exposure to acute air pollution had no statistically significant effect on antisocial behaviour, but significantly reduced both psychological and physiological wellbeing. However, these effects do not remain statistically significant after adjusting for multiple hypothesis testing. We find no evidence that pollution affects cognitive ability, present bias, discounting, or risk aversion, four potential pathways which may explain the relationship between pollution and anti-social behaviour. Our study adds to the growing calls for purposefully designed and pre-registered experiments that strengthen experimental (as opposed to correlational or quasi-experimental) identification and thus allow causal insights into the relationship between pollution and anti-social behaviour.

Description

Keywords

Air pollution, Causal inference, Decision-making, Economic preferences, Environmental stressors, Randomised experiment, Social preferences, Humans, Air Pollution, Beijing, Cognition, China

Journal Title

Social Science and Medicine

Conference Name

Journal ISSN

0277-9536
1873-5347

Volume Title

Publisher

Elsevier
Sponsorship
ESRC (1801783)
Economic and Social Research Council (1801783)
Department of Land Economy, British Academy Award Research Funding, Corpus Christi College, Cambridge