The Direct Costs and Benefits of US Electric Utility Divestitures
Triebs, Thomas P.
Pollitt, Michael G.
Kwoka, John E.
Faculty of Economics
MetadataShow full item record
Triebs, T. P., Pollitt, M. G., & Kwoka, J. E. (2010). The Direct Costs and Benefits of US Electric Utility Divestitures. http://dx.doi.org/10.17863/CAM.5558
This paper studies the impact of divestiture on the efficiency and costs of electric utilities. The empirical literature shows that there exist economies of scope for electric utilities and that divestiture decreases distribution efficiency but increases generation efficiency. This paper is to bring together these different results. Our analysis covers distribution, transmission, and power sourcing. Our data is an unbalanced panel of about 138 US electric utilities for the years 1994 to 2006 over which we observe 30 divestitures between 1997 and 2003. First, we regress firmlevel efficiencies for distribution and power sourcing on various divestiture indicators. Second, we compare the weighted cost between divested and non-divested firms and calculate a net present value for the entire sample of divestitures. Last, we regress net benefits from divestiture on the distribution side on the net benefit for power sourcing to see whether individual firms successfully off-set any costs of divestiture. We find that divestiture reduces distribution efficiency but increases power sourcing efficiency. Both effects depend on the amount of own nuclear generation output but not fossil-fuel or hydro output. The net present value for all divestitures in our sample is $11.3 billion. It seems that relatively lower costs of power outweigh losses in economies of scope as well as other restructuring costs. However, lower costs of power might be the result of favourable contracts put in place at the time of divestiture. Our study complements traditional studies of economies of scope and shows that divestitures might well be worth it.
Electric utilities, divestiture, economies of scope, net present value
This record's DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.17863/CAM.5558