Repository logo
 

The construction of 'learning cultures' : an ethnographically-informed case study of a UK conservatoire


No Thumbnail Available

Type

Thesis

Change log

Authors

Perkins, Rosie Louise 

Abstract

This study investigates the 'learning cultures' of a UK conservatoire of music. As educational institutions; conservatoires remain largely unresearched and, crucially, relatively unchallenged. In particular, existing research has paid little attention to indepth studies of culture, so that not enough is known of the cultural practices that characterise and shape a conservatoire education. To address this gap, the study adopts the conceptual lens of 'learning cultures'. Acknowledging recent research in further education, 'learning cultures' are conceptualised not as the contexts in which people learn, but as the practices through which people learn. As such, the study aims to understand the characteristic practices of the conservatoire and its members, the ways that learners participate in, construct and learn from such practices and, thus, the constructed nature of the conservatoire's learning cultures. Methodologically, the study is grounded in constructionism and draws on the thinking of Pierre Bourdieu. In particular, Bourdieu's notions of habitus, capital and field are used as 'thinking tools' through which to access and understand 'learning cultures'. The research comprised an ethnographically-informed qualitative case study of one UK conservatoire. In the quest for in-depth understandings, a family of four methods was employed: semistructured interviews, participant observation, document analysis and participant selfdocumentation. Data were analysed using a framework that moved between inductive data-driven thematic analysis and Bourdieu-informed interpretation, with emphasis given to the socially constructed nature of 'learning cultures'. The key findings of the study are divided into three interrelated parts: the organisational, curricula and spatial practices of the conservatoire, the practices of the conservatoire's students, teachers and staff and the ways in which different learners participate in, construct and learn from these practices. Drawing these parts together, the study concludes that (1) the nature of the conservatoire's learning cultures is manifested across four intertwined features: cultures privileging the development of specialised performers, cultures of social networking, cultures of musical hierarchies and cultures of vocational position taking and (2) the conservatoire's learning cultures are constructed in different ways for differently positioned learners, appearing to privilege those 'superstar' students who visibly demonstrate high levels of symbolic cultural and social capital. In a climate where the call to 'change the cultures' of conservatoires is oft heard, the learning cultures of this particular conservatoire reveal practices that do not always appear to reflect a rapidly changing musical field. Implications of the study are discussed, and recommendations made for the introduction of creative, reflective and leadership spaces for learning in the conservatoires of the future.

Description

This thesis is not available on this repository until the author agrees to make it public. If you are the author of this thesis and would like to make your work openly available, please contact us: thesis@repository.cam.ac.uk.


Cambridge University Library can make a copy of this work available only for the purposes of private study and non-commercial research. Copies should not be shared or saved in any shared facilities. Copyright over the content of these works is with their authors. Theses from the Library collection are considered unpublished works and according to UK legislation quoting from them is not allowed without permission from their author.

If you can commit to these terms, please complete the request form which you can find through this link: https://imagingservices.lib.cam.ac.uk/


Please note that print copies of theses may be available for consultation in the Cambridge University Library's Manuscript reading room. Admission details are at http://www.lib.cam.ac.uk/collections/departments/manuscripts-university-archives

Date

Advisors

Keywords

Qualification

Doctor of Philosophy (PhD)

Awarding Institution

University of Cambridge