Automated Object Segmentation in Existing Industrial Facilities
View / Open Files
Authors
Advisors
Date
2020-07-18Awarding Institution
University of Cambridge
Author Affiliation
Department of Engineering
Qualification
Doctor of Philosophy (PhD)
Language
English
Type
Thesis
Metadata
Show full item recordCitation
Agapaki, E. (2020). Automated Object Segmentation in Existing Industrial Facilities (Doctoral thesis). https://doi.org/10.17863/CAM.52102
Abstract
Shape segmentation from point cloud data is a core step of the digital twinning process
for industrial facilities. However, this process is labour-intensive with 90% of the cost being
spent on converting point cloud data to a model. This counteracts the perceived value of the
resulting model in managing and retrofitting the facilities and motivates the use of automation
to reduce this cost. In the US alone, unplanned factory shutdowns due to maintenance cost
$50 billion per year. Better documenting the existing conditions can significantly circumvent
irreversible damages and decrease the frequency of shutdowns, thus boosting the productivity
of industrial assets. This explains why there is a huge market demand for less labour-intensive
industrial documentation.
Shape segmentation in the literature has so far mostly focused on cylinders, with state-of-
the-art methods achieving 60-70% precision and recall for cylinder detection. Such
performance is promising, but far from drastically eliminating the manual labour cost, as
all other shapes have to be segmented manually. Yet the search space is massive; industrial
facilities contain thousands of object types, making automated detection an impossible
problem. Hence, there is a direct need to prioritise the most tedious to model objects.
The objective of this PhD research is to devise, implement and benchmark a novel framework
that can accurately generate individual labelled point clusters of the most important
shapes of existing industrial facilities with minimal manual effort in a generic point-level
format. This is addressed by first identifying the most important shapes to be modelled and
then developing algorithms to efficiently detect those shapes. The former is achieved by
answering the following three general research questions: a) what are the most frequent
industrial object types?, b) what is the time to model the most frequent object types in
state-of-the-art commercial software? and c) what is the performance of state-of-the-art tools
in terms of automated object detection? The proposed methodology employs a statistical
analysis to identify the most frequent industrial object types and then manually models those
to estimate the average man-hours needed for each type. Then, it evaluates the state-of-the-art
automated cylinder extraction tool and concludes a 64% reduction in manual modelling
time of cylinders. This leads to focus on reducing the remaining man-hours for cylinder modelling as well as for manual modelling of the remaining industrial objects, which are still
substantial. This is achieved by answering the following technical research questions: (1)
how to automatically segment the most important industrial shapes from point cloud data
with varying point densities and occlusions without relying on prior knowledge? (2) how to
minimise the time for manually assigning class labels to points? and (3) how to automatically
segment instance point clusters with less manual labour compared to the state-of-the-art?
The proposed framework employs a combination of deep learning and geometric methods
to segment the points into classes and individual instances. Along the way, the author
generates the largest to-date dataset of laser scanned industrial facilities used for training and
evaluation. Experiments reveal that the method can work reliably in complex and incomplete
point clouds of industrial facilities, yielding 82% class segmentation accuracy. Compared to
the current state-of-practice, the proposed framework can realise estimated time-savings of
30% on average.
Contributions. This PhD research provides the unprecedented ability to rapidly and
intelligently segment point clusters based on quantitative measurements. This is a huge leap
over the current practice and a significant step towards the automated generation of industrial
Digital Twins. As a result, the knowledge created in this PhD research will enable the future
development of novel, automated applications for real-time factory maintenance, planned
and unplanned downtime reduction.
Keywords
Digital Twin, Industrial Factory, Point Cloud Data, Deep Learning, Class Segmentation, Instance Segmentation
Sponsorship
Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) Award Ref. 1759297, AVEVA Group Plc. Grant, National Academy of Engineering Charles M. Vest Scholarship at MIT
Identifiers
This record's DOI: https://doi.org/10.17863/CAM.52102
Rights
Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0)
Licence URL: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
Statistics
Total file downloads (since January 2020). For more information on metrics see the
IRUS guide.