Repository logo
 

Accommodated authority: Broadening the picture

Accepted version
Peer-reviewed

Type

Article

Change log

Authors

Abstract

Speaker authority can spring into existence via accommodation mechanisms: a speaker acts as if they had authority and they can end up obtaining it if nobody objects. Versions of this claim have been advanced by Rae Langton, Ishani Maitra, Maciej Witek, and others. In this paper, I shift the focus from speaker to hearer authority. I develop a three-staged argument, according to which (i) felicity conditions for illocution can be recast in presupposition terms; (ii) just as certain illocutions require speaker authority, there are also illocutions requiring hearer authority; (iii) accommodation may provide a way to confer authority to one’s audience, rather than gain it for oneself. Speakers sometimes act as if their hearer had authority, and the hearer can end up obtaining it solely by playing along. In closing, I pause on the potentially problematic interplay between informal authority conferral and social norms of female deference to men.

Description

Keywords

5003 Philosophy, 50 Philosophy and Religious Studies

Journal Title

Analysis (United Kingdom)

Conference Name

Journal ISSN

0003-2638
1467-8284

Volume Title

Publisher

Oxford University Press (OUP)