Space-time philosophy reconstructed via massive Nordström scalar gravities? Laws vs. geometry, conventionality, and underdetermination


Change log
Authors
Pitts, JB 
Abstract

Klein-Gordon gravity, 1920s-30s particle physics, and 1890s Neumann-Seeliger modified gravity suggest a "graviton mass term" algebraic in the potential. Unlike Nordstr"om's "massless" theory, massive scalar gravity is invariant under the Poincar'e group but not the 15-parameter conformal group. It thus exhibits the whole Minkowski space-time structure, indirectly for volumes. Massive scalar gravity is plausible as a field theory, but violates Einstein's principles of general covariance, general relativity, equivalence, and Mach. Geometry is a poor guide: matter sees a conformally flat metric due to universal coupling, but gravity sees the rest of the flat metric (on long distances) in the mass term. What is the true' geometry, in line with Poincar\'e's modal conventionality argument? Infinitely many theories exhibit this bimetric geometry,' all with the total stress-energy's trace as source; geometry does not explain the field equations. The irrelevance of the Ehlers-Pirani-Schild construction to conventionalism is evident given multi-geometry theories. As Seeliger envisaged, the smooth massless limit yields underdetermination between massless and massive scalar gravities---an unconceived alternative. One version easily could have been developed before GR; it would have motivated thinking of Einstein's equations along the lines of his newly reappreciated "physical strategy" and suggested a rivalry from massive spin 2 for GR (massless spin 2, Pauli-Fierz 1939). The Putnam-Gr"unbaum debate on conventionality is revisited given a broad modal scope. Massive scalar gravity licenses a historically plausible rational reconstruction of much of space-time philosophy in light of particle physics. An appendix reconsiders the Malament-Weatherall-Manchak conformal restriction of conventionality and constructs the `universal force' in the null cones.

Description
Keywords
Bateman-Cunningham conformal group, Nordstrom scalar gravity, Conventionalism, Underdetermination, Explanation and geometry
Journal Title
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part B - Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics
Conference Name
Journal ISSN
1355-2198
1879-2502
Volume Title
53
Publisher
Elsevier BV
Sponsorship
John Templeton Foundation (38761)
Thanks to Jeremy Butterfield, Huw Price, John Barrow, Harvey Brown, Oliver Pooley, Don Howard and Katherine Brading for encouragement, Marco Giovanelli for finding the Reichenbach appendix, Nic Teh for discussion, and the referees for very helpful comments. This work was funded by the John Templeton Foundation Grant #38761.