Repository logo
 

Harmfulness and Wrongfulness in Sex-by-Deception

Published version
Peer-reviewed

Repository DOI


Type

Article

Change log

Authors

Abstract

jats:titleAbstract</jats:title>jats:pIn jats:italicCriminalizing Sex</jats:italic>, Stuart Green wisely eschews any attempt to fully analyse the problem of ‘sex-by-deception’ in a single chapter, instead offering a ‘basic framework’ for determining whether an expansion of the law of ‘rape by deceit’ might be justified. In this article, I offer a revision to that framework. Green begins from an account of rape centred on the right to (negative) sexual autonomy and seeks to reject an expansionist account under which any deceptions and mistakes could vitiate consent to sexual activity. Sharing these starting points, I argue, jats:italicpace</jats:italic> Green, that variations in the harmfulness and wrongfulness of different deceptions cannot ground jats:italiccontent</jats:italic>-based restrictions on consent-vitiating deceptions. I argue that whilst different kinds of deceptive practices might wrong V to a greater or lesser extent, these variations lead to content-neutral, jats:italicform</jats:italic>-based restrictions on consent-vitiating deceptions. Moreover, whilst variations in the harms of D’s conduct are unlikely to ground a coherent set of content-sensitive restrictions on consent-vitiating deceptions, the harms of jats:italiccriminalisation</jats:italic> differ depending on the content of the deception in question and this might lead to content-based restrictions on liability. However, an analysis of the variable costs of criminalisation is not obviously connected to the moral concept of consent-validity. Accordingly, whilst I suspect that both form and content-based restrictions on consent-vitiating deceptions are warranted in this area, the justification for the latter is unlikely to lie within an analysis of consent-validity itself, or the varied harmfulness and wrongfulness of D’s own conduct.</jats:p>

Description

Keywords

5003 Philosophy, 48 Law and Legal Studies, 50 Philosophy and Religious Studies, 16 Peace, Justice and Strong Institutions

Journal Title

Criminal Law and Philosophy

Conference Name

Journal ISSN

1871-9791
1871-9805

Volume Title

Publisher

Springer