Repository logo
 

Performance Comparison of Classical Methods and Neural Networks for Colour Correction.

Published version
Peer-reviewed

Repository DOI


Change log

Authors

Kucuk, Abdullah 
Finlayson, Graham D  ORCID logo  https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4040-0554
Mantiuk, Rafal 

Abstract

Colour correction is the process of converting RAW RGB pixel values of digital cameras to a standard colour space such as CIE XYZ. A range of regression methods including linear, polynomial and root-polynomial least-squares have been deployed. However, in recent years, various neural network (NN) models have also started to appear in the literature as an alternative to classical methods. In the first part of this paper, a leading neural network approach is compared and contrasted with regression methods. We find that, although the neural network model supports improved colour correction compared with simple least-squares regression, it performs less well than the more advanced root-polynomial regression. Moreover, the relative improvement afforded by NNs, compared to linear least-squares, is diminished when the regression methods are adapted to minimise a perceptual colour error. Problematically, unlike linear and root-polynomial regressions, the NN approach is tied to a fixed exposure (and when exposure changes, the afforded colour correction can be quite poor). We explore two solutions that make NNs more exposure-invariant. First, we use data augmentation to train the NN for a range of typical exposures and second, we propose a new NN architecture which, by construction, is exposure-invariant. Finally, we look into how the performance of these algorithms is influenced when models are trained and tested on different datasets. As expected, the performance of all methods drops when tested with completely different datasets. However, we noticed that the regression methods still outperform the NNs in terms of colour correction, even though the relative performance of the regression methods does change based on the train and test datasets.

Description

Peer reviewed: True


Publication status: Published

Keywords

colour correction, exposure invariance, neural network, optimisation, polynomial, regression

Journal Title

J Imaging

Conference Name

Journal ISSN

2313-433X
2313-433X

Volume Title

9

Publisher

MDPI AG
Sponsorship
Spectricity and EPSRC (EP/S028730)