Repository logo

Conservation Performance of Tropical Protected Areas: How Important is Management?

Published version



Change log


Peres, Carlos A 
Leader-Williams, Nigel 


Increasing the coverage of effectively managed protected areas (PAs) is a key focus of the 2020 Aichi biodiversity targets. PA management has received considerable attention, often based on the widely-held, but rarely examined, assumption that positive conservation outcomes will result from increased PA management inputs. To shed light on this assumption, we integrated data on PA management factors with 2006-2011 avoided forest degradation and deforestation across the Peruvian Amazon, using a counterfactual approach, combined with interviews and ranking exercises. We show that while increasing PA management input to Amazonian PAs tended to reduce likelihoods of forest degradation and deforestation, the associations were weak. Key challenges facing PAs ranked by PA managers included wider law enforcement, corruption and land title issues, rather than local management factors. We therefore encourage the post-2020 conservation targets to adopt holistic approaches beyond PA management, incorporating political, institutional and governance contexts across scales.



conservation outcomes, corruption, deforestation, forest degradation, governance, land title conflicts, law enforcement, politics, protected area management effectiveness

Journal Title

Conservation Letters

Conference Name

Journal ISSN


Volume Title


John Wiley & Sons Inc.
This work was supported by the Economic and Social Research Council (grant number ES/I019650/1); Cambridge Political Economy Society; Cambridge Philosophical Society; St John’s College; and the Department of Geography, University of Cambridge.