Repository logo
 

Rethinking Prestige Bias

Published version
Peer-reviewed

Change log

Authors

Chellappoo, Azita 

Abstract

Some cultural evolution researchers have argued for the importance of prestige bias as a systematic and widespread social learning bias, that structures human social learning and cultural transmission patterns. Broadly speaking, prestige bias accounts understand it as a bias towards copying ‘prestigious’ individuals (which are typically described as high-status, due to a high level of skill or success in a socially valued domain, and so are treated by others with respect and deference). Prestige bias, along with other social learning biases, has been argued to pay a crucial role in allowing cumulative cultural selection to take place, thereby generating adaptations that are key to our success as a species.

However, I argue for skepticism about the plausibility and scope of a prestige bias account. I argue that although an account of prestige bias seems plausible or compelling on their face, it is committed to a particular view of the cognition underpinning the bias, and therefore to predictions regarding its flexibility and context-sensitivity. Given this, current empirical evidence gives us reason to doubt the explanatory value of a prestige bias account over a naive, goal-directed agent account. Additionally, the way that prestige is defined in empirical work is in tension with a general understanding of prestige, casting doubt upon its status as evidence of prestige bias. I examine two studies cited as evidence of prestige bias, arguing that in these cases we cannot clearly favour a prestige bias explanation over a goal-directed agent explanation.

Description

Keywords

50 Philosophy and Religious Studies, 5002 History and Philosophy Of Specific Fields, Basic Behavioral and Social Science, Behavioral and Social Science

Journal Title

Synthese: an international journal for epistemology, methodology and philosophy of science

Conference Name

Journal ISSN

0039-7857
1573-0964

Volume Title

Publisher

Springer Nature
Sponsorship
AHRC (1791870)