INTRODUCTION: Silent sinus syndrome (SSS) is a rare disorder with protean manifestations. An absence of familiarity with ambiguous and atypical presentations may complicate diagnosis and delay management. CASE PRESENTATION: A 28year old female patient presented with a chronic history of headache, post-nasal discharge and recurrent facial pain refractory to analgesics. Enophthalmos and hypoglobus progressed over a period of 2 months, and a diagnosis of SSS was confirmed via imaging. Definitive treatment was withheld given the patient's postpartum state and improvement of symptoms. DISCUSSION: SSS typically manifests with painless and progressive, unilateral, enophthalmos and hypoglobus. Since presentation is dominated by ophthalmologic complaints, the ordinary route by which SSS is diagnosed is through ophthalmology review. The predominant complaint in our patient was chronic headaches with facial pain, and mild enophthalmos and hypoglobus were only noted 2 months later at follow-up. This represents an atypical presentation of SSS, and exemplifies the subtle and often ambiguous presenting features of this disorder. CONCLUSION: The protean manifestations of SSS mean that patients may initially present to specialities other than ophthalmology. To ensure rapid diagnosis and appropriate management, it is important that clinicians, particularly in ophthalmology, maxillofacial surgery, and ears, nose and throat (ENT), are familiar with this obscure condition.