Assessment of a multiplex PCR and Nanopore-based method for dengue virus sequencing in Indonesia.
Yudhaputri, Frilasita A
Salvaña, Edsel M
Destura, Raul V
Myint, Khin S
Frost, Simon DW
MetadataShow full item record
Stubbs, S., Blacklaws, B., Yohan, B., Yudhaputri, F. A., Hayati, R. F., Schwem, B., Salvaña, E. M., et al. (2020). Assessment of a multiplex PCR and Nanopore-based method for dengue virus sequencing in Indonesia.. Virology journal, 17 (1), 24. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12985-020-1294-6
Background: Dengue virus (DENV) infects hundreds of thousands of people annually in Indonesia. However, DENV sequence data from the country are limited, as samples from outbreaks must be shipped across long-distances to suitably equipped laboratories to be sequenced. This approach is time-consuming, expensive, and frequently results in failure due to low viral load or degradation of the RNA genome. Methods: We evaluated a method designed to address this challenge, using the ‘Primal Scheme’ multiplex PCR tiling approach to rapidly generate short, overlapping amplicons covering the complete DENV coding-region, and sequencing the amplicons on the portable Nanopore MinION device. The resulting sequence data was assessed in terms of genome coverage, consensus sequence accuracy and by phylogenetic analysis. Results: The multiplex approach proved capable of producing near complete coding-region coverage from all samples tested (x ̅ = 99.96%, n = 18), 61% of which could not be fully amplified using the current, long-amplicon PCR, approach. Nanopore-generated consensus sequences were found to be between 99.17 - 99.92% identical to those produced by high-coverage Illumina sequencing. Consensus accuracy could be improved by masking regions below 20X coverage depth (99.69 – 99.92%). However, coding-region coverage was reduced at this depth (x ̅ = 93.48%). Nanopore and Illumina consensus sequences generated from the same samples formed monophyletic clades on phylogenetic analysis, and Indonesian consensus sequences accurately clustered by geographical origin. Conclusion: The multiplex, short-amplicon approach proved superior for amplifying DENV genomes from clinical samples, particularly when the virus was present at low concentrations. The accuracy of Nanopore-generated consensus sequences from these amplicons was sufficient for identifying the geographic origin of the samples, demonstrating that the approach can be a useful tool for identifying and monitoring DENV clades circulating in low-resource settings across Indonesia. However, the inaccuracies in Nanopore-generated consensus sequences mean that the approach may not be appropriate for higher resolution transmission studies, particularly when more accurate sequencing technologies are available.
This study was co-funded by the UK Medical Research Council and the Indonesian Science Fund (DIPI) as part of the UK-Indonesia Joint Health Research Call on Infectious Diseases (2016). SDWF was supported in part by The Alan Turing Institute via an Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council grant.
External DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s12985-020-1294-6
This record's URL: https://www.repository.cam.ac.uk/handle/1810/302766
Attribution 4.0 International
Licence URL: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/